← Garden

Essay · Cinema · 16 Mar 2026

I called 19 of 24 Oscars. Publicly. Before the envelope opened.

On Oscar night I posted my full ballot to X. No edits after the fact. Here is how it held up against the 98th Academy Awards.

The public post

I shared all 24 picks in a thread on X before the ceremony wrapped up:

https://x.com/soneshzen/status/2033298811133817138

Monday, 16 March 2026 · 3:16 AM IST

Oscar predictions categories 1 through 12
Oscar predictions categories 13 through 24

18/24

Exact winners

22/24

Correct through runner-up

0

Post-hoc edits to the thread

Why I wrote it down in public

Oscar pools are fun because they force you to commit. Posting the ballot removes the luxury of hindsight. Either you called it or you did not. I had strong reads on the Sinners vs. One Battle After Another split, Frankenstein sweeping crafts, and KPop Demon Hunters taking animation and song. I also knew the first-ever casting category and several shorts categories were coin flips.

The misses mostly came from the same story: two films dominated the night, and I leaned Sinners where the Academy leaned One Battle After Another, or I picked the right film family but not the exact winner in a tight category. That is where the 22/24 runner-up score comes from. Only two picks were genuinely off the board.

Category by category

#CategoryMy pickWinnerResult
1Best PictureSinnersOne Battle After AnotherMiss
2Best DirectorPaul Thomas AndersonPaul Thomas AndersonHit
3Best ActorMichael B. Jordan (Sinners)Michael B. Jordan (Sinners)Hit
4Best ActressJessie Buckley (Hamnet)Jessie Buckley (Hamnet)Hit
5Best Supporting ActorSean Penn (One Battle After Another)Sean Penn (One Battle After Another)Hit
6Best Supporting ActressAmy Madigan (Weapons)Amy Madigan (Weapons)Hit
7Best Original ScreenplayRyan Coogler (Sinners)Ryan Coogler (Sinners)Hit
8Best Adapted ScreenplayOne Battle After AnotherOne Battle After AnotherHit
9Best Animated FeatureKPop Demon HuntersKPop Demon HuntersHit
10Best International FeatureNorway (Sentimental Value)Sentimental Value (Norway)Hit
11Best Documentary FeatureThe Perfect NeighborMr. Nobody Against PutinMiss
12Best Documentary ShortAll the Empty RoomsAll the Empty RoomsHit
13Best Animated ShortButterflyThe Girl Who Cried PearlsMiss
14Best Live Action ShortTwo People Exchanging SalivaTwo People Exchanging SalivaHit
15Best Original ScoreLudwig Göransson (Sinners)Ludwig Göransson (Sinners)Hit
16Best Original Song"Golden" (KPop Demon Hunters)"Golden" (KPop Demon Hunters)Hit
17Best CinematographyOne Battle After AnotherSinnersMiss
18Best Film EditingAndy Jurgensen (One Battle After Another)Andy Jurgensen (One Battle After Another)Hit
19Best Production DesignFrankensteinFrankensteinHit
20Best Costume DesignKate Hawley (Frankenstein)Kate Hawley (Frankenstein)Hit
21Best Makeup & HairstylingFrankensteinFrankensteinHit
22Best SoundF1F1Hit
23Best Visual EffectsAvatar: The Way of WaterAvatar: Fire and AshMiss
24Best CastingSinners (Francine Maisler)One Battle After Another (Cassandra Kulukundis)Miss

What I got wrong (and how close it was)

  • Best Picture: picked Sinners, won One Battle After Another. Both were the two-horse race all season.
  • Best Documentary Feature: picked The Perfect Neighbor, won Mr. Nobody Against Putin. The Perfect Neighbor was in the hunt; the category stayed volatile.
  • Best Animated Short: picked Butterfly, won The Girl Who Cried Pearls. Butterfly was on the shortlist; a tight category.
  • Best Cinematography: picked One Battle After Another, won Sinners. Historic win for Autumn Durald Arkapaw; Sinners vs. One Battle was the split.
  • Best Visual Effects: picked Avatar: The Way of Water, won Avatar: Fire and Ash. Same universe, wrong subtitle on my ballot. The franchise call was right.
  • Best Casting: picked Sinners (Francine Maisler), won One Battle After Another (Cassandra Kulukundis). First year of the category; again the Sinners vs. One Battle split.

Takeaway

The 98th Oscars belonged to two films in different ways. One Battle After Another took the night with six awards including the inaugural casting Oscar. Sinners made history with sixteen nominations and landmark wins in cinematography and score. If you were watching the season, the ballot was really about reading that duopoly correctly category by category.

I added every film from my ballot, plus full filmographies for Christopher Nolan, Quentin Tarantino, Alejandro González Iñárritu, and Guillermo del Toro, to my movies list. Watch this space for more public calls. I prefer committing in the open.

Follow along on X (@soneshzen).